What if: Which Spider-Man would win a in a fight? Tobey vs Andrew vs Tom

I found an interesting tweet about Spider-Man on Twitter in regards who win in a fight.

In the movie world, we have had three actors portray this web-slinging hero in the cinema. If you count TV actors, we have a total of five actors! The first actor was Nicholas Hammond who played as Peter Parker/Spider-Man in the 1970s series The Amazing Spider-Man. Around the same years in the late 70s, we had a Japanese version of Spider-Man and the actor who played as Spider-Man was Shinji Todo. Shinji Todo played as a character named Takuya Yamashiro and his character played as Spider-Man with a “Power Rangers” vibe but in a dark tone which involved death and suicide; the Japanese live action series is commonly known as Toei’s Supaidaman TV Series.

Getting back to topic, we had three movie actors who took the mask and became Spider-Man. The first actor of the Spider-Man movies was Tobey Maguire and he became Spider-Man in the Sam Raimi versions in 2002 and all the way to 2007 concluding in Spider-Man 3. In 2012, the Spider-Man got a reboot and without Sam Raimi, Marc Webb took control and with the help of Sony, we got the Amazing Spider-Man movies. Taking over the mask, we had Andrew Garfield and he appeared in two movies of the Amazing Spider-Man from 2012 to 2014. The third movie was cancelled because of the negative feedback on the second. With Disney buying Marvel, fans wanted Spider-Man to join the world of the Avengers. It was difficult since Spider-Manis owned by Sony and with the upcoming Captain America: Civil  War coming out, fans was like J. Jonah Jameson and asking for Spider-Man. The dream became a reality and we got a new and younger of Spider-Man to join the MCU. In 2016, we got Tom Holland playing as 15 year old Peter Parker and taking on real life villains like a hero and under the tutelage of Iron Man. Besides joining in Civil War and Infinity War, he also had his own solo movie in Spider-Man Homecoming and he’s going to be in the upcoming 2019 film Spider-Man: Far From Home.

Three different actors but they each play as the same character with the same powers. What if these Spider-Men were pitted against each and fought each other. Which Spider-Man would come out as a victor? Let’s go over some facts on these characters to help decide who would win.

Spider-Man (Tobey Maguire 2002-2007)

Starting off, we have Tobey’s Spider-Man. This Spider-Man in my opinion has a lot of strength and endurance. Not to mention, he has dealt with emotional pain when dealing with his friends and enemies and crush, Mary Jane. I like to point out that Spider-Man has incredible strength that could surpass Captain America. In Spider-Man 1, he can hold both Mary Jane and a tram car while dealing with Green Goblin. Iconic in this scene, we have Spider-Man 2 where stopped an out of control train with his webbing and himself. In Spider-Man 3, he faced many enemies and including himself. In this movie, he wears an alien suit that gives him strength but in return, he becomes more dark and aggressive. In the movie, he has to deal with the consequences of his actions and learn to not get stuck on revenge.

The Amazing Spider-Man (Andrew Garfield 2012-2014)

In this reboot, Andrew becomes Spider-Man. Even though he only has two movies, this Spider-Man is pretty unique and strong. Unlike Tobey wear he has infinite web fluids in his veins, Andrew creates his own webbing and the same goes with Tom Holland Spider-Man. Andrew Spider-Man, in my opinion, is probably the most agile out of the two; not to mention he is kind of durable. He’s agile as he was able to fight against Electro’s electricity and he has been able to go toe to toe with the giant reptilian villain The Lizard. With the pain of loss, Spider-Man also has a share of pain. In Tobey’s version, he lost Uncle Ben, his idol Dr. Otto Octavius, almost lost the love of his life Mary Jane and he lost his best friend Harry Osborn. In Andrew, he his losses are minimum but devastating. In the first movie, he lost Uncle Ben, his parents, and his girlfriend’s dad Captain Stacy. In ASM 2, he couldn’t help out his fan Electro, his best friend Harry went insane and tried to kill him after refusing to help cure his terminal illness and he lost the life of Gwen Stacy. Losing his girlfriend was so devastating that he stopped helping New York for a long time. He later does come back to help stop the villain Rhino after regaining his confidence. Even though this Spider-Man takes tragedy pretty rough, he still a strong hero and his speed and agility is great.

Tom Holland (2016-current)

This may be the youngest version of Spider-Man, but he’s definitely the strongest. He’s still young as a superhero, but he has potential of becoming an Avenger. Before meeting Tony Stark, Peter relied on his wits and his own tech to take down everyday crooks. In Homecoming, he even took down Vulture without Stark’s spider suit. In strength, Spider-Man has displayed incredible strength that could match up to Tobey. In Civil War, he was able to fight Captain America on his own and lift a piece of airplane parts on his own. In Homecoming, he lifted up broken rubble with his own strength when he was trapped by Vulture. In his Peter life, he had to learn about sacrifices. In Homecoming, he had sacrifice his priorities when learning how to be a hero like Iron Man. He left his team behind during a school field trip to pursuit Vulture and even had to abandon his date with Liz in order to defeat her father in which was Vulture. With Tony’s tech, he’s actually pretty skilled. He has many web shooter gadgets where that can be used on enemies based on style. When he removes the training wheels setting, he has all access to his tech but there is one he would never use and that’s the instant kill mode. If he did used it on Tobey and Andrew, he could instantly win. If he used the Iron Spider suit from Infinity War, he would be able to use his Spider Legs mode for more strength and mobility.  Overall, without Tony’s assistants, Tom Spider-Man is pretty strong and he has enough room for experience. With the suits, he will be able to survive fights and make use of his tools.

Who will win?

With these facts said, who would win in a fight? Comment down below on your thoughts.

Please donate to my Ko-Fi: http://ko-fi.com/matthat

Advertisements