I know I’m late to the news, but I feel like bringing it up. When it comes manga, we want to experience whatever Japan is getting. That’s why most of us either pay for it like Shonen Jump or some read from the scan sites. However, according to fans, fans are not liking the tactics Square Enix is doing with their manga. Recently released, Square Enix started this global digital manga service app called Manga UP!. With this app service, fans can pay to read their favorite Square Enix manga such as Soul Eater, My Dress-Up Darling and Fullmetal Achemist. Unfortunately, according to fan’s experiences, the service is off to a bad start. Fans have shown that Manga Up has releasing censored pages of the manga. Characters revealing skin or even full clothed are censored with black bars. Even if a woman is wearing suitable bottom clothes like pants/jeans, black bars will appear around their genitalia area. Fans were enraged to see the over the top censors.
How do you feel about this news?
In short: screw that!
I haven’t tried the app service so I can’t confirm if it’s still there. Still, kind of crazy that SE would do this.
Disappointing there’s a lot of censoring (I mean, knees??) and over-the-top warnings.
Yeah I was looking at the pictures and it’s crazy that they’re censoring clothes or at least a percent of skin.
I think censorship should only go so far as to have a warning at the beginning of the chapter for mature content, because some people aren’t into that and they should be given a heads up. But actually going so far as to cover up the mangaka’s artwork? That’s not okay!
Yeah I agree. It feels like they’re not respecting the creator’s work if they censor their pages. If anything, I feel like the app should have a parental security pin for young readers.
Censors are trying to take over the world. Soon all eye candy will be prohibited. By the right or the left, it doesn’t matter.
It stinks. Eventually, they’ll probably go after translation next. At this point, I would stick with physical books instead of digital.
In theory I’m not opposed to the concept but they’re just censoring everything. I saw someone’s shoulders being censored in one scan
Yeah I’m not sure what’s up over there. I heard reports that they’re censoring fully clothed girls.
Pingback: ICYMI: Censorship in Square Enix manga app? — Matt-in-the-Hat | The Official Christyleinc. Blog